Osmond Resources — homeASX: OSM · Orión Project

Minerals Hub / Sustainability / The energy a hard ore costs

Sustainability · 4 min read

The energy a hard ore costs

Crushing and grinding are among the largest energy uses in US mining on one government count, and the published estimates of how large differ in what they measure; this piece sets them out with their bases, and shows which steps loose sands avoid.

Reviewed by Peter Uppal

Tight close-up of a few steel grinding balls filling the frame, their surfaces scuffed and pitted, worn out of round to slightly different sizes.
Illustrative artwork: a few worn steel grinding balls, seen close. Not a facility, equipment or material connected to this project. · Illustration · Osmond Hub

The short version

Published estimates of comminution's (crushing and grinding's) share of energy run from typically 25% of mining's final energy consumption, in a Weir-commissioned report of 2021, to up to 70% of a plant's energy in some hard-rock cases, in figures a 2024 review reports from earlier work. A US Department of Energy study of year-2000 data found grinding the largest energy-consuming equipment type in US mining (excluding oil and gas, counting electricity losses), at 40%. USGS describes heavy-mineral sands as generally easy to excavate, sparing the costs of blasting, rock crushing and grinding. By USGS's account of that advantage, a consolidated ore that needs blasting and crushing does not get that saving.

How big the bill is, by one government count

One government study breaks the total down by equipment. The US Department of Energy's Mining Industry Energy Bandwidth Study, prepared in June 2007 using year-2000 data, found that US mining, excluding oil and gas, consumes approximately 1,246 trillion Btu a year(opens in a new tab). Within that year-2000 US total, the largest energy consuming equipment types are grinding (40%) and materials handling (17%)(opens in a new tab), counting the energy lost in generating the electricity. The study counts crushing separately; on this publication's arithmetic from its own tables, crushing and grinding together come to about 44% of US mining energy in 2000.

The DOE study estimated that investments in state-of-the-art equipment and further research could reduce energy consumption to 579 trillion Btu a year(opens in a new tab), against a theoretical minimum of 184 trillion Btu a year, a value the study says it could not source as a single figure(opens in a new tab), because of the wide variability in mining processes.

The share depends on what it is a share of.

How efficiently it is used

The DOE study also looked at how efficiently that energy is used. It notes that estimates of crushing and grinding efficiency vary widely with the metric used(opens in a new tab), whether new surface area per unit of energy or the motor efficiency of the equipment. For grinding, it reports that 1% efficiency was found to be the most common estimate in the literature it compiled(opens in a new tab), while the same table gives a current crushing efficiency of 50%, reported by AOG (2005)(opens in a new tab).

A 2012 paper to the International Mineral Processing Congress also describes comminution's energy use as substantial. Its abstract says the crushing and grinding steps in the mineral processing of ores represent a substantial proportion of total energy(opens in a new tab), and, citing Fuerstenau and Abouzeid (2002), that current practices of breaking rocks in tumbling mills are relatively inefficient(opens in a new tab).

Why hardness raises it

One index links hardness and energy. A 2024 review in Minerals states that the Bond Work Index directly correlates with the energy required to reduce an ore to a specific particle size(opens in a new tab), and that the index can also be estimated from ore characteristics including density and ore hardness(opens in a new tab), a point it draws from a 2016 study.

The Minerals review reports that comminution typically accounts for 30% to 50% of the total energy used in the plant, depending on the material and process(opens in a new tab), and that in some cases, such as in hard rock mining, this figure can reach up to 70%(opens in a new tab). Those figures come from works it cites dating from 1996 to 2014, not from new measurement.

The range, and who publishes it

The other figures come from an equipment maker. Mining Energy Consumption 2021, a report commissioned by the Weir Group, which sells comminution equipment, found comminution typically accounting for 25% of mining's final energy consumption(opens in a new tab), as reported by Engineering & Mining Journal. In December 2023, a Weir study presented at a COP28 panel said comminution consumes around 3% of the world's electrical power each year(opens in a new tab) and is responsible for at least one-third of an average mine's energy use and CO2e emissions(opens in a new tab).

The two Weir figures, typically 25% in 2021 and at least one-third in 2023, come from the same company and are not reconciled in what was published. On this publication's reading, the spread across all these numbers is largely, though not wholly, a spread of denominators: the DOE's 40% is grinding's share of US mining energy in 2000, Weir's 25% is a share of mining's final energy, its one-third is a share of an average mine, and the review's 30–50% is a share of a processing plant.

What loose sand spares

The contrast with mineral sands starts with the deposit. The USGS deposit model says heavy-mineral sands deposits are relatively easy to mine because they are weakly to poorly consolidated(opens in a new tab). The resulting sands are typically well sorted, medium- to fine-grained, well-rounded, and not indurated(opens in a new tab). Among the advantages USGS lists, these deposits are generally easy to excavate, which spares costs associated with blasting, rock crushing, and grinding(opens in a new tab). By USGS's own account of that advantage, a consolidated ore that needs blasting and crushing does not get that saving.

Related

  • Ore Processing
  • Processing Technology
  • Environmental Management
  • Mining Methods
  • Processing Innovation

Sources